Guide · Ads

Google Ads Quality Score for roofers, remodelers and tree services: what it measures and the fixes that matter

Your Google Ads account shows a 3/10 next to "roof replacement", or a rep tells you your Quality Score is low. What that number measures, what Google says it does and does not do, and the few ad group, ad and landing page fixes that matter for a roofing, remodeling or tree company.

  • By Kausar Ahmed, Founder, Digital Hark
  • Updated
  • 11 min read

The short answer

Quality Score is Google's 1–10 rating for each Search keyword, based on expected clickthrough rate, ad relevance and landing page experience. Google calls it "a diagnostic tool" and says it "is not an input in the ad auction". Use it to find weak ad groups, ads and pages; judge every change by signed jobs.

Key takeaways

  • Quality Score is a summary, shown per keyword. Google: "Quality Score is not an input in the ad auction." The auction uses its own real-time quality checks.
  • Three parts, each rated "Above average", "Average" or "Below average" against other advertisers on the exact same search.
  • In our view, a low score in a contractor account usually points to mixed ad groups, ads that do not name the job, or a page that does not match the search.
  • Bidding more does not raise it. Google: "You don't need to bid for higher positions to increase Quality Score."
  • Google says it "should not be optimized". Fix the ad, the ad group and the page, then judge by signed jobs.

All Google quotes on this page are from Google Ads Help. Google moves menus often: if a button has a new name, follow Google's current label. What clicks cost is in our Google Ads guide for contractors; this page is only about Quality Score and gives no cost figures.

What is Google Ads Quality Score?

Google: "Quality Score is a diagnostic tool meant to give you a sense of how well your ad quality compares to other advertisers." "This score is measured on a scale from 1-10 and available at the keyword level." Google's page is called "About Quality Score for Search campaigns", so the score belongs to Search keywords. This guide does not cover Performance Max or Local Services Ads; Local Services Ads rank ads with their own, different system.

Quality Score, 1-10 per keyword

Built from three parts: expected clickthrough rate, ad relevance and landing page experience.

The score is built from three parts. Google's definitions:

PartGoogle's definitionThe question to ask (our view)
Expected clickthrough rate (CTR)"The likelihood that your ad will be clicked when shown."Would a homeowner who searched this click this ad?
Ad relevance"How closely your ad matches the intent behind a user's search."Does the ad say the job they searched for?
Landing page experience"How relevant and useful your landing page is to people who click your ad."Does the page show that job and your area, make calling easy, and work well on a phone?

"Each component is evaluated with a status of “Above average,” “Average,” or “Below average.”" The comparison is with "other advertisers whose ads showed for the exact same search over the last 90 days." So a roofer's ad is not graded against a perfect ad. It is graded against the other roofing ads that showed on "roof leak repair" in recent months.

Google also says: "It's a diagnostic tool to identify how ads that show for certain keywords affect the user experience."

One number people mix up with it: the optimization score on the Recommendations page is a different number and is not used by your Quality Score; see does the optimization score matter.

Does Quality Score change what you pay?

Not directly, and this is where many guides get it wrong. Google is plain: "Quality Score is not an input in the ad auction." Its ad quality page says the same: "these scores are not inputs in the ad auction. Use Quality Score to diagnose low quality ads, rather than trying to optimize the 1-10 score you receive."

What the auction does use is Ad Rank. Google: "At a high level, Ad Rank scores are based on 6 factors:" In plain words, those are your bid, the quality of your ad and landing page, Google's minimum thresholds, how competitive the auction is, the context of the search, and your assets. Google's glossary puts it this way: "Ad Rank scores are calculated based on many factors, including your bid amount, the quality of your ads and landing page."

How do the two connect? Google: "Our assessment of the quality of your ad is summarized in your Quality Score." The auction itself uses "auction-time measurements like expected CTR, ad relevance, and landing page experience." So the 1–10 number is a report card on past searches. The same three kinds of quality are checked again, live, in every auction.

Does better quality cost less? Google says: "Higher quality ads can often lead to lower CPCs." Note the words "can often": that is Google's statement, not a rule, and we do not put a figure on it. Your bid is a separate lever: "The amount you bid may affect your Ad Rank, but it doesn't impact the assessment of your ad quality." And positions move: "Your ad position can fluctuate each time depending on your competition."

Want to see who else shows on your searches? Our guide to seeing your competitors' ads covers Auction insights.

Where do you see your Quality Score?

Many owners never see it, because it is hidden at first. Google: "The Quality Score column is disabled in new accounts."

To turn it on: go to Campaigns, then Keywords, click the columns icon, choose to modify columns for keywords, and open the Quality score section. The columns are:

  • Quality Score, Landing Page Exp., Exp. CTR, Ad Relevance (today's view)
  • Quality Score (hist.), Landing Page Exper. (hist.), Ad Relevance (hist.), Exp. CTR. (hist.) (history, so you can see whether a change helped)

Google adds: "You can hover over each keyword's status to learn about performance details like Quality Score."

Why does a keyword show a dash? Google: "it means there aren't enough searches that exactly match your keywords to determine a keyword's Quality Score." "Quality Score is based on historical impressions for exact searches of your keyword." In our view, this is normal in a small local account. A tree service in one county will see dashes on long keywords such as "emergency oak tree removal after storm". It is not a problem to fix.

What does a low Quality Score usually mean for a contractor?

Google does not list contractor causes. These are the usual causes we look for, with made-up examples:

  • Roofer, one ad group for everything. "Roof repair", "roof replacement", "metal roof" and "storm damage roof" sit in one ad group with one ad and point to the home page. Hits: ad relevance and landing page experience. No single ad can match four different jobs.
  • Roofer, wrong job in the ad. Someone searches "roof leak repair" and sees an ad that leads with "Roof Replacement in [City]". Hits: expected CTR and ad relevance. The searcher wants a leak fixed, not a new roof.
  • Remodeler, kitchen, bath and basement in one group. One ad says "Home Remodeling" for all three. Hits: ad relevance. A homeowner who typed "bathroom remodel" wants to see bathrooms.
  • Tree service, one page for every job. "Emergency tree removal" and "tree trimming" both land on a general "Our Services" page. Hits: landing page experience. The emergency searcher needs a call button and the words "emergency tree removal" at the top, not a list of services.
  • Any trade, a slow or vague page. The page loads slowly on a phone, or never names the job or the town. Hits: landing page experience.
Water stain on a ceiling from a roof leak, with a bucket on the floor catching drips.
Someone searching roof leak repair wants a leak fixed, not a new roof.

Each one maps to a fix below.

Which fixes matter most?

1. Split ad groups by job type. Google, for low ad relevance: "Split these ad groups into multiple ad groups that are a better match to the user's searches." For a contractor that means one ad group per job (repair, replacement, storm; kitchen, bath, basement; removal, trimming, storm cleanup). The full setup for each trade is in our trade guides, so it is not repeated here: how to set up roofing campaigns, how a remodeler should set up Google Ads campaigns and what a tree service ad and landing page should say. To stop one ad group from catching another's searches, use cross-negatives to keep your own campaigns apart. The settings section of our Google Ads guide covers the other settings that waste money.

2. Write ads that name the job and the town. Google, for expected CTR: "Be more specific in your ad text." "Ensure the details in your ad match the intent of your keywords." And for ad relevance: "Match the language of your ad text more directly to user search terms." So the "roof leak repair" ad group gets a headline about leak repair in your town, not a general roofing line. The roofing guide's ad section shows what to put in the ad.

3. Send each ad group to a page about that job. Google: "Keep messaging consistent from ad to landing page." "Make your website mobile friendly." A "bathroom remodel" ad lands on a bathroom remodel page with your own bathroom photos, your service area and a call button. In our view, speed matters too: a page that loads slowly on a phone loses the homeowner before they read it. What a good contractor page needs, and how fast it should load, is on our landing pages page; the landing page section of the roofing guide shows the parts for a roofer.

Google's own advice is to use the score as "a general indicator of which areas to focus on to improve ad quality" "rather than a score to be optimized." Look at which of the three parts says "Below average", and fix that part first.

Roofer's hands replacing a few damaged shingles on a small roof repair.
Give each job its own ad group, ad and page, such as roof repair or replacement.

What does not change Quality Score?

Things owners are told, and what Google says:

  • "Bid more and the score goes up." No. "You don't need to bid for higher positions to increase Quality Score." Bidding is its own topic; see our bid strategy guide.
  • "Your account has a low Quality Score." There is no such score. "There is no such thing as ad group-level, campaign-level or account-level Quality Score." Quality Score is per keyword.
  • "Change the match type." Google: "changing keyword match types will not impact Quality Score."
  • "Move the ad group to a new campaign." Google: "moving an ad group with the same ads and keywords to another campaign or account doesn't impact your ad quality."
  • "Add more assets to lift the score." Google: "We also normalize for other factors that affect visibility, like ad assets and other ad formats." Assets do count in Ad Rank (one of its factors), but they are not a way to lift the 1–10 number.
  • "Display and search partner results drag it down." Google: Display and search partners "won't affect your ads' quality on Google.com."

One thing that does matter: "The user's device (laptop, tablet, smartphone or whatever) is taken into account when ad quality is calculated." Many homeowners search for a roofer or a tree service on a phone, so test your ads and pages on a phone.

Should you chase a higher Quality Score?

No. Google: "Quality Score is not a key performance indicator and should not be optimized or aggregated with the rest of your data." And: "focus on delivering relevant ads to answer queries rather than trying to optimize to manipulate your score."

Your number is signed jobs. Judge each change by how many leads became signed jobs and by your cost per signed job. For the landing page, Google says conversion rate "doesn't impact your landing page status", but suggests: "Try using conversion rate as a proxy for good landing page experience." We would take it one step further, to signed jobs.

Worked numbers in this guide show the method; they are not real client results. Say a roofer splits one mixed "roofing" ad group into three: repair, replacement and storm, each with its own ad and page. In the two months before, the old group brought 20 leads and 3 signed jobs. In the two months after, the three groups bring 22 leads and 5 signed jobs, and two keywords move from "Below average" to "Average" ad relevance. The score change is a sign the ads fit better. The signed jobs are the result that counts.

Before and after the split

Worked numbers in this guide show the method; they are not real client results.

Give changes time. The score looks back at past searches, so it may take weeks to move, and Google does not promise it will move at all.

Where Digital Hark fits

When we run Google Ads for contractors, we set up ad groups, ads and landing pages by job type, check the three Quality Score parts for weak spots, and judge every change against the signed jobs your team marks in your CRM. Your team answers the leads and sells the jobs; we never do that for you. The Google Ads account stays yours.

Common questions

What is a good Quality Score?

Google gives no target number. Each part is rated "Above average", "Average" or "Below average" against other advertisers on the same search. Google says Quality Score is not a key performance indicator and should not be optimized. Fix any "Below average" part, then judge by signed jobs.

Does Quality Score affect my cost per click?

Not directly. Google says Quality Score is not an input in the ad auction; it is a diagnostic tool. The auction uses live checks of expected CTR, ad relevance and landing page experience, plus your bid and other factors, to set your Ad Rank. Google's own words on cost are quoted in the guide above.

Why does my keyword show a dash instead of a Quality Score?

Google says a dash means there are not enough searches that exactly match your keyword to give it a score. In our view, that is common in small local accounts and on long keywords. It is not an error.

Do assets (extensions) raise my Quality Score?

Not the 1–10 number. Google says it normalizes for factors that affect visibility, such as ad assets and other ad formats. Assets are one of the Ad Rank factors, so they still matter in the auction.

Does bidding more improve my Quality Score?

No. Google says you don't need to bid for higher positions to increase Quality Score, and that your bid may affect Ad Rank but does not change the assessment of your ad quality.

Is the optimization score the same as Quality Score?

No. The optimization score on the Recommendations page is a different number, and it is not used by your Quality Score. Our auto-applied recommendations guide explains it.

Kausar Ahmed, Founder, Digital Hark. Digital Hark runs Google and Meta ads, landing pages, tracking and follow-up systems for home-service contractors. We are not affiliated with Google. About Digital Hark

Find out where your leads are being lost

Book a free Growth Diagnosis. We review your ads, website and follow-up, and send you a short written summary of the top leaks and what to fix first.

Check my ad groups and landing pages

We reply within 24 hours

Free Growth Diagnosis