Guide · Trust
Contractor awards and badges: which ones count, which to skip, and how to show them honestly
Which awards help roofers, remodelers and tree services, how to spot a "best of" award you pay for, and how to show a real one.
The short answer
An award helps when a homeowner can see who gave it, why and when. Platform awards earned from reviews and real local votes can help; "you've won, now pay for the plaque" offers usually don't. Name the award and the year, link the giver, and judge it by signed jobs. General information, not legal advice.
Key takeaways
- BBB says: "Most legitimate awards do not come with costs to the recipient."
- The FTC treats an organization's name or seal as an endorsement, and calls paid-for rankings on a "review" site deceptive.
- "Award-winning" alone tells a homeowner nothing; name the award, giver and year (our advice).
- Never put an award in your Google Business Profile name.
Want us to find your three biggest lead leaks?
Free Growth DiagnosisScope: roofers, remodelers and tree services. NARI and NKBA awards are covered in our guide to NARI and NKBA membership; other credentials have their own guides, linked below.
Which kinds of awards are there?
Our split, so you can say which kind you hold:
| Kind | Example | What it tells a homeowner |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Earned, free to be considered | Best of Houzz Service and Design | Houzz's own users and reviews picked you |
| 2. Earned inside a platform or membership you pay for | Angi Super Service Award; GuildQuality Guildmaster; NARI/NKBA awards (see that guide) | You did well with that platform's customers or survey |
| 3. Popularity vote | A local newspaper's readers' choice contest | Many local people voted for you |
| 4. Size list | Qualified Remodeler Top 500 | Your company is large, not that its work is good |
| 5. "You've won, now pay for the plaque" | The vanity-award pattern BBB describes | Nothing you can check |
Houzz. Houzz says Service badges are based on "Houzz rating and client reviews", Design badges on user engagement and ideabook saves, and "Consideration for awards is free, automatic, and based on your profile, rating, and reviews". See is Houzz Pro worth it.
Angi. Angi's award is earned from ratings and reviews, but only pros active on Angi and in good standing can win it. See is Angi worth it.
GuildQuality. GuildQuality says: "The Guildmaster Awards are open to all active GuildQuality members." and "we consider two metrics... customer recommendation rate and survey response rate." So it is paid to take part, earned to win, from real customer surveys.
Qualified Remodeler Top 500. The magazine calls it "The 48th annual ranking of the nation's largest firms based on remodeling revenue." Show it as "ranked by remodeling revenue", not as a quality award.
How do you spot a "best of" award you pay for?
BBB says: "Trusted, hardworking businesses deserve recognition, but not the kind you have to pay for." It adds: "Vanity awards exist in virtually every industry and for every profession." and "A typical vanity award scam starts with an email." One e-mail reported to BBB offered a city "Best" award in Houston.
BBB's red flags, in one regional director's words:
- "You're asked to pay a fee for the award"
- "It requires few or no qualifications besides payment"
- "Someone sent you an unsolicited email about it"
- "You didn't apply for the award but were named a winner"
- "You've never heard of the award company before"
A two-minute check before you reply (our list, built from BBB's advice):
- Who gives it? BBB: "Learn everything you can about who is giving the award, where they are located, how long the award has existed and how your business was selected as a winner."
- How were you nominated? "If you didn't apply for it or the organization cannot tell you how you were nominated, chances are the award is not legitimate."
- Is there a fee to win, or for the plaque? "Most legitimate awards do not come with costs to the recipient." "If there is a fee, scrutinize it closely."
- Don't click the link. "Be wary about clicking on links in emails from strangers." "Scammers often hide malware in email links."
- Search the name. BBB says to check the company's BBB Business Profile. The FTC's general advice for small businesses (about fake bills, not awards) fits here too: "Know who you’re dealing with." and "search online for the company’s name with terms like “review,” “scam,” or “complaint.”"
- Report it. "To report a vanity award scheme, visit BBB Scam Tracker."
A fee alone does not prove an award is fake; some awards need a paid membership to compete (kind 2 above). The question is whether a real judgment stands behind the win.
General information, not legal advice.
What does the FTC say about awards and seals?
The FTC's Endorsement Guides are "administrative interpretations of laws enforced by the Federal Trade Commission for the guidance of the public". Three lines matter for awards:
- A seal can be an endorsement. The Guides say "the name or seal of an organization can be endorsements." An endorsement is a message "consumers are likely to believe" "reflects the opinions, beliefs, findings, or experiences of a party other than the sponsoring advertiser". The FTC's guides on seals add: "A marketer's use of the name, logo, or seal of approval of a third-party certifier or organization may be an endorsement".
- It has to reflect a real judgment. "Endorsements by organizations, especially expert ones, are viewed as representing the judgment of a group", and "an organization's endorsement must be reached by a process sufficient to ensure that the endorsement fairly reflects the collective judgment of the organization."
- Paid-for rankings are deceptive. In one of the Guides' examples, a "review" site ranks businesses by who pays; the FTC says "such paid-for rankings are deceptive and the website operator is liable for the deception."
What it means for you (our reading). These lines are about organizations and review sites. They do not ban showing an award, and they do not say a contractor breaks the law by showing one. But a homeowner reads your badge as someone else's judgment, so a badge you bought proves little and can mislead.
Customer reviews and photos have their own FTC rules; see our guide to customer reviews and photos in your ads. To keep proof for every claim in your ads, see our guide to free inspection and warranty ads.
General information, not legal advice.
Are local readers' choice awards worth entering?
A readers' choice contest is a popularity vote run by a newspaper. One Ohio paper's rules show how it works (Ohio is not one of our markets; other contests have their own rules): "readers can propose businesses, organizations and names for all of the categories", then readers vote. "Voting is limited to one vote in each category per person per day." Businesses are "prohibited from soliciting votes by offering payments or exchange of value of any kind".
Some papers also sell advertising around the contest. One Pennsylvania paper's contest page (Pennsylvania is not one of our markets either) offers "High-visibility advertising packages to amplify your brand" and "A FREE marketing toolkit to help you rally your customers and drive votes". That page does not say ads change the results, and neither do we.
Our advice. A win shows many people voted for you; it is not a quality check. So:
- Name it for what it is: "Voted [category], [paper] Readers' Choice [year]".
- Ask past customers to vote within the contest's rules, by e-mail or text (texts only with consent).
- Never offer anything for a vote.
General information, not legal advice. Read your contest's own rules.
How should you word "award-winning"?
"Award-winning" alone can't be checked. Name the award, the giver and the year, and link to the giver's page when there is one (our advice, not a legal rule).
| Instead of | Write |
|---|---|
| "Award-winning roofer" | "Angi Super Service Award [year]" (or the award you really hold), linked to the giver's page |
| "Best remodeler in town" (no source) | Drop it, or "Voted [category], [paper] Readers' Choice [year]" |
| A row of six badges | The two or three you can explain, each one linked |
| "Best of Houzz" with no year | "Best of Houzz Service [year]" |
| "Top 500 remodeler" | "Qualified Remodeler Top 500 [year], ranked by remodeling revenue" |
Keep the year on old awards. An old badge should never read as this year's.
Follow the giver's logo rules. Angi, for example, lists "Company website" and "Yard signs at job sites" among the places "SSA winners may use the logo". Read your award's rules before you put it on a truck or an ad.
The same idea works for other trust words; see our guide to bonded and insured wording.
General information, not legal advice.
Where does a real award belong?
Our advice on placement:
- Your landing page, in the trust strip next to the form. Our landing pages for contractors put trust items there.
- Your estimate or proposal, one line with the award, giver and year.
- Your About page, with a sentence on what the award measures.
- Your Business Profile photos or updates, as a picture of the badge or the project.
- Not your Business Profile name. Google says: "Including unnecessary information in your business name isn't permitted, and could result in the suspension of your Business Profile." Its list of what the name "must not include" has "Marketing taglines". An award in the name is a tagline. See what name your profile should use (our guide has remodeler and tree service versions too).
Turn award-winning projects into project pages with before and after photos (our NARI and NKBA guide's advice).
General information, not legal advice.
Roofers, remodelers and tree services: what changes?
Roofers. Shingle makers run their own contractor tiers and awards; see our guide to roofing manufacturer certifications. Google's own badge in Local Services Ads is not an award; see how Google verifies roofers.
Remodelers. You have the most award routes (Houzz, GuildQuality, Qualified Remodeler, NARI and NKBA); say which kind each one is, as in the table above.
Tree services. ISA certification and TCIA Accreditation are credentials, not awards; see our guide to ISA Certified Arborist and TCIA Accreditation. Your main award routes are local readers' choice contests and BBB's own ethics award: BBB St. Louis names "our Torch Awards for Ethics".
How do you know an award is worth the time?
Judge an award by signed jobs, not by how it looks.
- Ask every new lead "How did you hear about us?" and write the answer in your CRM.
- Tag jobs where the homeowner names the award, or that came from the platform that gave it.
- Count signed jobs over 6 to 12 months and compare them with the hours you spent and any fee.
Our BBB guide shows the method: how many extra jobs a trust badge must win. To compare every lead source the same way, use cost per signed job.
Where Digital Hark fits
We run Google and Meta ads and build websites and landing pages for contractors. When a client holds a real award, we show it on the landing page and in the ads with the giver, the year and a link. Your company stays responsible for its claims and its ads. Calls, estimates and sales stay with your team.
Common questions
Is a "best of" award e-mail a scam?+
Not always, but check it first. Find out who gives it and how you were picked, without clicking the link. General information, not legal advice.
Do real awards cost money?+
BBB says: "Most legitimate awards do not come with costs to the recipient." Some, such as Angi's and GuildQuality's, are open only to pros on a platform or in a membership you pay for. General information, not legal advice.
How are Best of Houzz winners chosen?+
From Houzz reviews, ratings and user engagement. Houzz says being considered is free and automatic. General information, not legal advice.
Can I put an award in my Google Business Profile name?+
No. Google's guidelines say the name must not include "Marketing taglines". General information, not legal advice.
Are readers' choice awards real?+
They are real votes, not quality checks. Name the paper, the category and the year when you show a win. General information, not legal advice.
How long can I show an old award?+
No source sets a limit. Our advice: keep the year on every award, and drop it if you can't say when you won it. General information, not legal advice.


