Guide · Trust
Is BBB accreditation worth it for contractors? What BBB says, and how to decide
What a BBB profile, a BBB rating and accreditation each are, what BBB says about dues and grades, and a simple way to work out how many extra jobs the badge must win before you pay.
The short answer
BBB accreditation can be worth it if your buyers check BBB and a few extra signed jobs a year cover the dues. You already get a free BBB profile and a rating without paying, and BBB says dues do not buy a rating. So check your free profile, track where jobs come from, then decide.
Key takeaways
- BBB says accreditation "is voluntary and separate from the rating," and that dues "do not buy a rating, and they do not remove a complaint."
- BBB publishes profiles for accredited and non-accredited businesses alike. Not being accredited "is not a mark against the business," BBB says.
- BBB says "Customer reviews do not affect the rating."
- To apply, BBB asks for "a B rating or better" and "at least six months of serving customers." BBB can revoke accreditation later.
- BBB says accreditation fees "are based on several factors, including the size of business," and that accredited businesses pay an annual dues investment. Ask your local BBB for a written quote.
Want us to find your three biggest lead leaks?
Free Growth DiagnosisIs BBB accreditation worth it for contractors?
It depends on two things you can check yourself: do the homeowners you sell to look at BBB before they hire, and would a few extra signed jobs a year cover the dues?
Accreditation tends to fit when:
- your jobs are big and planned, so homeowners take time to check you out,
- prospects or their families ask about BBB on sales calls,
- your free BBB profile already shows a good rating and complaints answered well, and
- one or two extra signed jobs a year would cover the dues.
It tends to be a weak fit when your jobs are small and fast, when nobody in your area ever mentions BBB, or when you have no way to tell which signed jobs came from which source.
You do not have to pay to be on BBB. BBB says it publishes profiles "for Accredited and non-accredited businesses alike." So you can check your free profile and your sales calls first, then decide whether to pay.
Every BBB fact in this guide is quoted from BBB's own pages.
What is the difference between a BBB profile, a BBB rating and accreditation?
These three things are often mixed up. They are not the same.
The profile. BBB's page about your business. BBB says: "We publish profiles for Accredited and non-accredited businesses alike. Every profile states clearly whether the business is accredited." You may already have one, whether you asked for it or not.
The rating. The letter grade on that profile, from A+ to F. BBB says: "Accreditation is voluntary and separate from the rating. We base the rating on the business's complaint history and its interactions with customers, not on whether it pays dues."
Accreditation. A paid status. Your business agrees to BBB's standards, pays yearly dues, and the profile shows that it is accredited. BBB's Get Accredited page says: "Businesses are under no obligation to seek BBB accreditation".
The line that matters most for your decision, in BBB's words: "Accreditation dues do not buy a rating, and they do not remove a complaint." And on not being accredited: "On its own, it is not a mark against the business."
So paying does not change your grade. What you pay for is the accredited status on your profile, and being held to BBB's standards.
How does BBB set your rating?
BBB says: "We calculate them from a business's complaint history, how it responds to complaints, how transparent it is about its practices, and any licensing or government action against it."
BBB's overview of ratings lists seven elements:
- Complaint history
- Type of business
- Time in business
- Transparent business practices
- Failure to honor commitments to BBB
- Licensing
- Advertising issues
BBB says: "Each element adds or deducts points on a 100-point scale." An A+ is 97 to 100 points, and an F is 0 to 59.99. A profile can also show "NR", which means No Rating.
What is not in the grade. BBB says: "Customer reviews are not used in the letter-grade calculation." BBB's FAQ says the same: "Customer reviews do not affect the rating."
What this means for you: the parts of the grade you control most are how you answer complaints, keeping your licences in order, and being clear in your ads and contracts.
What do you need to qualify, and what do you sign up for?
To apply. BBB says: "We invite businesses with a record of delivering on their promises and a B rating or better. You also need at least six months of serving customers."
BBB's accreditation standards also say: "Fulfill all competency and trade licensing requirements." and "Maintain at least a B rating in all company-owned locations and its headquarters". If your state or city licenses your trade, your licence needs to be in order before you apply.
What you agree to. BBB's accreditation standards have eight parts:
- Build trust
- Advertise honestly
- Tell the truth
- Be transparent
- Honor promises
- Be responsive ("Address disputes forwarded by BBB quickly and in good faith.")
- Safeguard privacy
- Embody integrity
It can be taken away. BBB says: "We monitor Accredited Businesses against the BBB Standards for Trust and can revoke accreditation when a business stops meeting them." So accreditation is not a one-time purchase. Your team has to keep answering complaints and keep your ads and contracts clean.
What does BBB accreditation cost?
BBB's standards page says: "BBB accreditation fees are based on several factors, including the size of business." The Get Accredited page says: "Accredited Businesses pay an annual dues investment."
So you pay yearly dues, set by your local BBB. You will see dollar figures in other guides, but they come from other sources, differ by region and change over time, so we do not repeat them here. The only figure that counts is the one your local BBB gives you.
Before you sign, ask your local BBB for a written quote, and ask:
- What are the yearly dues for a business my size, in writing?
- Is there a separate fee to apply, or to use the accredited seal on my website and trucks?
- Do the dues renew on their own? On what date, and how do I cancel?
- What exactly is included for the dues?
- What data can you show me about how often people view businesses in my trade and city? (Ask for the source and the period.)
How many extra jobs must BBB win to pay for itself?
Skip the dollar math for a moment and think in jobs. The question is: how many extra signed jobs per year must accreditation win to cover its yearly dues?
Jobs needed per year = your yearly dues ÷ your profit per signed job.
Use profit, not the job price. A job's profit is what is left after materials, labor and other job costs.
Worked numbers in this guide show the method; they are not real client results.
The table compares the profit from one signed job with your yearly dues. The shares are our inputs, chosen only to show the method. They are illustrative only and not real results. Use your own dues quote and your own profit per job.
| Job type | Profit from one signed job, compared with your yearly dues (our input) | Extra signed jobs needed per year to cover the dues |
|---|---|---|
| Roof repair | about one quarter of your yearly dues | about 4 |
| Bathroom remodel | about one and a half times your yearly dues | less than 1 (one job covers it) |
| Tree removal | about one sixth of your yearly dues | about 6 |
What the table shows: for a big job like a remodel, one extra signed job a year can cover the dues. For smaller jobs, the badge has to tip several homeowners your way every year.
Two more things to count:
- "Extra" means extra. A job counts only if the homeowner would have hired someone else without the badge. A homeowner who found you on Google and would have signed anyway does not count.
- Your time is a cost too. Answering complaints through BBB, renewing and keeping your profile up to date take staff time. Aim well above break-even, not at it.
To see what each source really costs you per job, use our guide to cost per signed job. It shows how to measure every lead source the same way, so you can compare BBB with the rest.
Is BBB worth it for roofers, remodelers and tree services?
Roofers
Roof replacements are big, planned purchases. If your sales calls show that buyers compare roofers, check that your free BBB profile shows a good rating, your licence and your address, because it is one more thing they can look at. If you work storm areas, make sure your local address and licence number are on your profile and your estimates. Your free BBB profile shows the rating either way. For small, fast repair calls, if your leads say they never checked BBB, accreditation is unlikely to pay back. Our guide to roofing leads compares the main lead sources for roofers.
Remodelers
Kitchen and bath remodels are big, planned projects. If your leads tell you they checked BBB, count those jobs. Because one remodel can leave a lot of profit, the break-even is easy to reach if accreditation really tips even one job a year. The hard part is knowing whether it did, so ask every new lead how they found you and whether they checked you anywhere. Our guide to remodeling leads covers the lead sources remodelers use.
Tree services
Tree jobs are often smaller than roofs or remodels, so the math is tighter: you need more extra signed jobs to cover the same dues. Tree work also has its own trade accreditation: TCIA Accreditation from the Tree Care Industry Association is a different, trade-specific program, and our guide to ISA and TCIA credentials for tree services explains what it checks and how to show it.
For every trade: before you pay, look at your own free BBB profile and at the profiles of the companies you lose jobs to. If none of them is accredited and they still win work, BBB may not be what homeowners in your area use to decide.
BBB vs Google reviews: which matters more for local leads?
They do different jobs. BBB's grade comes from complaint history, licensing and the other elements above, and BBB says customer reviews do not change it. Google reviews are a separate source with their own rules. See our guide to Google reviews for roofers and remodelers.
How do you test BBB before you pay, and before you renew?
- Find your free profile. Search bbb.org for your business. Check the name, address, phone, licence and service area, and ask BBB to fix what is wrong.
- Answer every complaint. BBB says it will "contact the business, ask for a response, and act as a neutral intermediary." A calm, quick answer helps your rating whether you pay or not.
- Ask every new lead how they found you, and whether they checked you anywhere. Write the answer down.
- Log the source of every signed job in your CRM, with a field for "mentioned BBB". After a few months you will see whether BBB comes up at all.
- Get the written quote and run the break-even from the section above, with your own profit per job.
- Write your rule before you pay. For example: "If BBB comes up in at least as many signed jobs per year as the break-even says, we keep it at renewal. If not, we let it lapse and keep the free profile."
- Put the renewal date in your calendar a few weeks early, so you decide on purpose.

If you already pay, run the same steps before your next renewal. Our guide to cost per signed job shows how to set up the tracking.
What else builds trust with homeowners?
BBB is one trust signal among several, and many of the others are free:
- Your licence and insurance, shown clearly on your website, estimates and trucks. Only show what you really have.
- Google reviews. See our guide to Google reviews for roofers and remodelers.
- Your Google Business Profile, complete, with real photos and your service area.
- Photos of finished jobs and your crew at work, on your site and profile.
- Trade bodies and manufacturer programs you really belong to. The same goes for awards; see how to tell earned contractor awards from paid ones.
- A written estimate and a written contract, every time.
BBB is not a lead platform, so it is a different decision from paid lead sites. If you are weighing those too, see is Angi worth it?, and our guides to whether Thumbtack is worth it, whether Houzz Pro is worth it and whether Yelp advertising is worth it.
Where Digital Hark fits
Digital Hark runs Google and Meta ads, landing pages, tracking and follow-up systems for home-service contractors. We do not sell BBB accreditation and we are not part of BBB. What we can help with is the tracking: knowing which source each signed job came from, so a decision like this one is based on your own numbers. We never call your leads or sell jobs for you; your team does that. You own every ad account, page and lead.
Common questions
Can I have a BBB profile without paying?+
Yes. BBB says it publishes profiles "for Accredited and non-accredited businesses alike," and that every profile states whether the business is accredited. BBB also says that not being accredited "is not a mark against the business" on its own. Look up your free profile on bbb.org and check it.
Does paying BBB raise my rating?+
No, according to BBB. BBB says accreditation "is voluntary and separate from the rating," and that "Accreditation dues do not buy a rating, and they do not remove a complaint." The grade comes from complaint history, licensing, time in business and the other elements BBB lists.
Do BBB customer reviews change my letter grade?+
No. BBB says "Customer reviews do not affect the rating" and are "not used in the letter-grade calculation."
Can BBB take accreditation away?+
Yes. BBB says it monitors accredited businesses against its standards and "can revoke accreditation when a business stops meeting them." Keep answering complaints, keep your licences current and keep your ads honest.
Do I have to answer BBB complaints?+
BBB says it contacts the business, asks for a response and acts as "a neutral intermediary," and that "We do not take sides, and we cannot force a business to act." How you respond is part of your rating, though, and accredited businesses agree to address disputes "quickly and in good faith." So answer every one.
Does BBB accreditation help Google rankings?+
BBB's pages we read make no claim about Google rankings, and we have seen no proof either way. Do not pay for accreditation to rank better.


