Guide · Measuring marketing

Contractor marketing KPIs: which numbers to check each month, and how to read an agency's report

The five counts a roofer, remodeler or tree service can take from its own phone log and CRM, what to check weekly and monthly, and how to tell if an agency's report shows real jobs.

  • By Kausar Ahmed, Founder, Digital Hark
  • Updated
  • 9 min read
Roofing company owner at his desk early in the morning checking his monthly marketing numbers

The short answer

Check five counts for each lead source: leads, leads your team reached, booked visits, estimates sent and signed jobs. Weekly, check that new leads are reached and booked; monthly, check signed jobs and cost per signed job by source. A good agency report shows the same counts, from your own accounts and CRM.

Key takeaways

  • The step where the count drops tells you where jobs are lost: marketing, follow-up or sales.
  • Weekly is about speed (are leads reached and booked?). Monthly is about results (which sources signed jobs?).
  • Clicks, impressions and rankings are work numbers for your agency, not proof of jobs.
  • If you cannot match a report's leads to your own phone log and CRM, ask why.

Which numbers should you check?

More on this in the measuring step of our contractor marketing plan.

Which marketing numbers should a contractor check?

Five counts, kept for each lead source, every month:

  1. Leads. A real homeowner who called, filled out a form or sent a message about a job you do. Count each person once: two calls and a form from the same person are one lead. Spam, sales calls and job seekers are not leads.
  2. Contacted. Someone on your team talked to them or answered them. An automatic reply does not count.
  3. Booked visit. An inspection, consultation or estimate visit put on the calendar.
  4. Estimate. A written estimate or proposal sent.
  5. Signed job. A signed contract.

Then look at the four steps between them. Each one points to a different part of the business:

  • Leads → contacted: follow-up. If leads come in but your team does not reach them, more ads will not fix it.
  • Contacted → booked visit: the first call and lead quality. Many reached leads but few visits can mean wrong-area or wrong-job leads, or a first call that does not ask for the visit.
  • Booked visit → estimate: the visit. No-shows and visits that never get a written estimate show up here.
  • Estimate → signed job: sales and estimate follow-up.

A weak first count (few leads, or many junk ones) points to the marketing itself: targeting, offer or landing page.

At the end, put spend next to the signed jobs for each source. That gives your cost per signed job, the one number that ties marketing money to work on your schedule; that guide shows the math and has a calculator.

Made-up counts, not real results

Worked numbers in this guide show the method; they are not real client results.

Source, one monthLeadsContactedBooked visitEstimateSigned job
Google search ads302715124
Facebook ads4022972

Facebook brought more leads, but 18 of them were never reached. The biggest loss is between lead and contacted, which is a follow-up problem before it is an ad problem. Judging Facebook by its lead count alone would hide that.

Why do clicks, impressions and rankings not answer the question?

Because none of them is a homeowner who called. Google's own definitions make that plain:

  • Impression: "An impression means that a user has seen (or potentially seen) a link to your site in Search, Discover, or News." A chance to be seen, not a lead.
  • Clicks: "How often someone clicked a link from Google to your site." A visit, not a lead.
  • Position: the report value is "averaged across all queries in which your property appeared", and Google warns it "can be misleading if you don't understand the subtleties." An average position is not "you are number N for roof repair".

They help whoever runs your marketing; our Quality Score guide explains why Google's own ad score is a diagnostic, not a result. In a report, they go under the lead and job counts.

How do you know where each lead came from?

Give every lead one source, picked from a fixed list in your CRM, on the first call. Whoever answers the phone or opens the form fills it in; make the field required. A short pick-list works better than a free-text box:

  • Google search ads
  • Google Business Profile / Maps
  • Website, found through search (not ads)
  • Facebook or Instagram ads
  • Lead sites (shared leads)
  • Referral from a past customer
  • Referral from a partner (realtor, insurance agent, other trade)
  • Yard sign or truck
  • Repeat customer
  • Other (write it in, and check these each month)

Then check the pick against what the systems saw. A separate tracking phone number for each channel, and the source field your website form records, tell you where most calls and forms came from. Our tracking service page shows how these pieces connect.

Ask "How did you hear about us?" anyway, but treat the answer as a check, not the only record. A pay-per-call lead vendor wrote in 2020 that the answer alone gives inaccurate data and suggested a tracking number per channel. A homeowner may name the last thing they remember seeing, not where they first found you.

Keep new and returning customers apart. The same 2020 article warned that mixing past customers into new-customer counts distorts the cost of getting a customer.

What should you check every week?

Ten to fifteen minutes, one person owns it, same day each week:

  • New leads by source, compared with last week. A source that drops to zero can mean a broken form, a paused campaign or a tracking number that stopped forwarding.
  • Every lead has a source.
  • Leads not yet contacted, and missed calls never called back. Look at names, not percentages, and assign each one today. The speed numbers worth tracking are in our speed-to-lead measures.
  • Booked visits this week and next, and last week's no-shows.
  • Spend that jumped or a campaign that stopped, in your own ad accounts.
  • Junk leads marked as junk, so they drop out of the monthly count.

Do not judge a source on one week of signed jobs; there are too few.

What should you check every month?

Once a month, look at results by source:

  • Estimates and signed jobs from each source.
  • Cost per signed job by source (spend from your ad accounts, jobs from your CRM).
  • Open estimates that are still waiting, so a slow month for signatures is not mistaken for a bad month for leads.
  • One or two changes for next month, written down, so next month's numbers can show whether they worked.

Count each signed job in the month its lead came in, not the month it signed. This keeps a slow-signing source, like kitchen remodels, from looking worse than it is. Last month's numbers will still grow for a while; recheck them.

Compare with your own past (last month, and the same month last year), not with someone else's numbers; storms, holidays and the season change every count.

How much to spend, and how to split it between sources, is in our guides to the roofing and remodeling marketing budget and the tree service marketing budget.

How do you read a marketing agency's report?

Whatever the format, a report you can trust passes four owner tests:

  1. The match test. Pick five leads from the report and find them in your phone log and CRM: name or number, date, source. If you cannot find them, the report counts something other than your leads.
  2. The follow-through test. Does the report go past leads to booked visits, estimates and signed jobs by source? Your team marks those in your CRM; a report that ignores them stops at the easy half.
  3. The own-account test. Can you open your own Google Ads, analytics and call tracking logins and see the same spend and lead counts?
  4. The change test. Does it say what was changed this month, why, and what happened after?

One agency's guide for business owners also puts leads by source first, calling it the most important part of any report.

Two words are worth asking about. Google Ads describes conversion tracking as a tool that can help "measure how clicks on your ads and free product listings lead to meaningful actions such as sales or leads." Google Analytics calls an important action a key event, and says a "conversion" now refers to "an important action that you want to use to measure the performance of your ad campaigns." So ask what each one counts in your account: a real call of a certain length, a form sent once, or only a page view. Our Performance Max guide uses the same rule: judge a campaign by signed jobs, not by Google's conversion count.

Some gap between Google, Meta and your CRM is normal; what matters is that someone can explain it.

What are the red flags in a marketing report?

None of these proves anything on its own. Each is a reason to ask why:

  • Only clicks, impressions, reach or rankings, with no lead count. One agency's owner guide lists impressions and reach without lead data as a red flag too.
  • No lead list. A lead total with no names, numbers or dates you can check.
  • Leads you cannot find in your phone log or CRM, or the same person counted twice.
  • Nothing past the lead: no booked visits, estimates or signed jobs, month after month.
  • Numbers you cannot see yourself, because the ad or analytics account belongs to someone else. Who should own what is covered in the ownership section of our leaving-an-agency guide.
  • The same report every month, with no notes from a person, and no word on what changed.

What should you ask your agency?

Monthly, or before you hire one:

  1. Can I see last month's lead list, with names or numbers, dates and sources?
  2. Which of those leads became booked visits, estimates and signed jobs?
  3. What counts as a conversion in my Google Ads account, and in my analytics?
  4. Whose account holds my ads, analytics and call tracking data?
  5. What did you change last month, and why?
  6. What would make you stop a campaign that brings leads but no booked visits?

A good agency will be glad you asked. If an answer is "trust us", ask again in writing.

Does it change by trade?

Roofers. In storm weeks the contacted step breaks first. Check uncontacted leads daily then, and judge storm-week sources on their own (roofing marketing).

Remodelers. Signed jobs come in slowly after the visit. Watch open estimates and count each job in the month its lead came in (remodeling marketing).

Tree services. Urgent calls (a tree on the house) and planned work behave differently. Give urgent calls their own pick-list value (tree service marketing).

Who does what?

  • Your team: answers leads and marks each step in your CRM.
  • Your agency, or you: reports spend and leads by source from your accounts.
  • You: run the checks and ask the questions.

Common questions

What are the most important marketing KPIs for contractors?

Five counts per lead source: leads, leads reached, booked visits, estimates and signed jobs. Add spend by source to get cost per signed job.

What is a good lead-to-job rate for a contractor?

There is no single number that fits every trade, area and season. Use your own last three to six months as the baseline, by source, and watch which step between lead and signed job drops.

How often should a contractor review marketing numbers?

Weekly for speed: new leads, who is not reached yet and booked visits. Monthly for results: signed jobs and cost per signed job by source.

What should a monthly marketing report include?

A lead list by source you can check, what became of each lead, spend from your own accounts and what changed. If its leads do not match your CRM, ask why.

Are impressions a good marketing metric?

Not on their own. Google says an impression means a user has seen, or potentially seen, a link to your site. That is a chance to be seen, not a homeowner who called.

What should I do if my agency's numbers don't match my CRM?

A small gap is normal, since no two systems count the same way. Ask for the lead list, match it to your CRM, and ask what each conversion counts; your CRM shows which leads became booked and signed jobs.

Kausar Ahmed, Founder, Digital Hark. Digital Hark runs ads, landing pages, tracking and follow-up systems for home-service contractors. This guide names and ranks no agency or report tool. About Digital Hark

Find out where your leads are being lost

Book a free Growth Diagnosis. We review your ads, website and follow-up, and send you a short written summary of the top leaks and what to fix first.

Check my lead-to-job numbers

We reply within 24 hours

Free Growth Diagnosis